Friday 25 March 2011

Roof Strength Evaluations

Rollover evaluations

Small cars

To measure roof strength, a metal plate is pushed against one corner of a vehicle's roof at a constant speed. The maximum force sustained by the roof before 5 inches of crush is compared to the vehicle's weight to find the strength-to-weight ratio. This is a good assessment of vehicle structural protection in rollover crashes.

Each model is rated based on our measured curb weight of a vehicle with typical engine, transmission, and equipment options. However, when the same model is available in a configuration over 10% heavier than the typically equipped vehicle, a separate rating is assigned.


Good Good   Acceptable Acceptable   Marginal Marginal   Poor Poor   |   Vehicles are listed in order of performance

Model Overall rating Curb weight (lb) Peak force (lb) Strength-to-weight ratio
Nissan Cube
2009-11 models
Good 2,833 20,569 7.26 









Scion xB
2008-11 models
Good 3,078 21,041 6.84
Scion tC
2011 models
Good 3,123 17,738 5.68
Mazda 3 sedan
2011 models mfg. after Dec. 2010
Good 2,922 15,541 5.32
Volkswagen Golf
2010-11 models
Volkswagen Rabbit
2006-09 models
Volkswagen GTI
2010-11 models
Good 3,042 15,970 5.25
Toyota Corolla
2009-11 models
Good 2,749 14,006 5.09
Mazda 3 hatchback
2011 models mfg. after Dec. 2010
Good 3,023 15,380 5.09
Chevrolet Cruze
2011 models
Good 3,143 15,944 5.07
Mini Cooper Countryman
2011 models
Good 2,984 14,829 4.97
Subaru Impreza wagon
2008-11 models
Good 3,132 14,485 4.62
Kia Forte
2010-11 models mfg. after Oct. 2009
Good 2,859 13,084 4.58
Subaru Impreza sedan
2008-11 models
Good 3,125 14,069 4.50
Honda Civic 4-door
2006-11 models
Good 2,760 12,532 4.48
Kia Soul
2010-11 models
Good 2,886 12,489 4.33
Mitsubishi Lancer
2008-11 models
Good 2,984 12,863 4.31
Rating does not apply to 4-wheel drive models. Rating of these models is Acceptable.
Honda Insight
2010-11 models
Acceptable 2,700 8,970 3.32

No comments:

Post a Comment